Are Protein Shakes Good for You?

Most Individuals get loads of protein. However that hasn’t hampered curiosity on this vital macronutrient: In 2024, protein complement gross sales within the U.S. elevated by 9%, in accordance with the market-research agency Statista.

Numerous that supplemental protein will get blitzed into shakes. However are protein shakes really wholesome?

Advantages of protein shakes

For those who’re involved you’re not getting sufficient protein, shakes supply a easy, handy option to get extra. That’s a boon particularly when you don’t have a ton of time to make and eat breakfast or to organize a refueling snack after a exercise, says registered dietitian Amy Bragagnini, spokesperson for the Academy of Diet and Dietetics.

Consuming protein after a exercise is particularly vital when you’re seeking to construct muscle, and shakes are hydrating and simple to drink within the hour or so afterward when your physique is most receptive to the nutrient, in accordance with the Nationwide Academy of Sports activities Drugs.

Shakes can’t exchange a balanced, nutrient-dense weight loss plan, however they’ll complement wholesome consuming habits, particularly when you actually do want extra protein, says household doctor Dr. Shannon Dowler, a board member of the American Academy of Household Physicians.

They are often particularly useful when you’re seeking to achieve weight safely, possibly since you’re under-nourished or going by means of a taxing medical therapy like chemotherapy, Dowler says.

Potential downsides to contemplate

Protein shakes don’t supply the vary of different vitamins you get in a well-rounded weight loss plan. “I wish to make sure that [people] aren’t including a protein shake to utterly get rid of complete meals or meals,” Bragagnini says.

It’s additionally essential to contemplate what goes into your shake. Protein powders are extremely processed and never the identical as getting high-protein meals in your weight loss plan. “Greek yogurt, flax seeds, chia seeds, or peanut butter [can] take the place of the protein powder,” Bragagnini says.

Plus, protein powder can also be technically a dietary complement, and dietary supplements aren’t regulated by the U.S. Meals and Drug Administration as strictly as prescription drugs are. Which means you’re not assured to get what the label claims.

Learn Extra: What’s Behind Your Persistent Cough?

For those who’re shopping for a bottled protein shake, learn the ingredient lists rigorously. You may discover these shakes are “really simply sugar-sweetened drinks that occur to have a little bit little bit of protein in them,” Dowler says.

Some packaged shakes might have synthetic sweeteners and sugar alcohols, which might make some folks really feel bloated and gassy, Bragagnini provides. Different elements, whereas not inherently “dangerous” for you, merely may not agree with you, like dairy when you’re lactose illiberal, Dowler says.

It’s additionally potential to get an excessive amount of protein, so contemplate your total consumption. “You’ll be able to really harm your kidneys with an excessive amount of protein when you have kidney challenges,” Dowler says. Extreme quantities of protein can even result in constipation, complications, and dangerous breath, per the Mayo Clinic.

The best way to inform when you’re getting sufficient protein

One of the best ways is to trace your meals and see the way it measures up towards diet suggestions. The official really helpful every day allowance of protein is 0.8 grams per kilogram of your physique weight per day, in accordance with the American Coronary heart Affiliation. (To seek out your physique weight in kilograms, divide your weight in kilos by 2.2.) However some consultants suggest aiming for extra like 1 gram of protein per pound of your physique weight when you train recurrently, per the Nationwide Academy of Sports activities Drugs.

If reaching that quantity of protein feels daunting, it might be value consulting with a health care provider or registered dietitian. “They are going to have the ability to analyze your energy, physique mass index, and different facets of your life-style, like how a lot you are exercising,” Dowler says. They’ll then “make particular suggestions on your physique and your life-style to hit the goal of how a lot protein you could get.”

The best way to make a wholesome protein shake

To decide on probably the most nutritious shake, hold the following pointers in thoughts: 

Add complete meals

Complement your protein powder with recent vegatables and fruits for a spread of minerals, nutritional vitamins, and electrolytes. “For those who’re somebody who would not love consuming a giant handful of spinach, you possibly can actually conceal it properly in a protein shake and nonetheless make it style good,” Dowler says.

Learn Extra: 10 Inquiries to Ask Your Mother and father Whereas You Nonetheless Can

Experiment with texture and temperature

Along with experimenting with flavors, take into consideration texture and temperature. Dowler, for instance, says she prefers her protein shakes “notably chilly” and “extremely puréed.” Tweak yours till you discover what works finest for you.

Keep on with quick elements lists

For those who’re shopping for a bottled shake, search for one with as few elements as potential, Bragagnini says.

Select protein powders with third-party verifications